With a inhabitants of just about 1.4 billion, there’s one subject the place Indians are virtually assured to dominate – recognition contests. In any competitors the place Indians have an affordable presence and which relies on public voting – on-line or on social media – there’s an excellent likelihood that they are going to come out on high.
The Indian males’s hockey workforce clinched the bronze medal on the Tokyo Olympics, whereas the ladies completed fourth. Creditable and historic as these achievements are, they completed behind Belgium and Netherlands, who completed on the highest step of the rostrum of their respective occasions. So, it’s nothing lower than a travesty that India ended up sweeping all eight classes on the FIH Hockey Stars Awards 2020-21.
It’s well-known that India supplies essentially the most eyeballs in world hockey and likewise generates the very best sponsorship. A mix of recognition and income era prompted the Worldwide Hockey Federation (FIH) to bend over backwards and assist make India one of many main gamers within the sport, on the turf. Getting them into elite tournaments for which they wouldn’t in any other case qualify and allotting internet hosting rights of a serious occasion yearly will be thought of administrative selections aimed to safe the well being of the worldwide sport. However when advertising and gimmicks to encourage fan engagement encroach upon what takes place on the sector, it’s time for alarm bells.
Sport is supposed to be a stage taking part in subject the place excellence and onerous work are rewarded, not simply recognition and the quantity of social media visitors one can generate. However in a sport with a lopsided income era mannequin, TV scores and backside line appear to trump what occurs on the pitch. There’s no different purpose for India internet hosting two out of the previous three males’s World Cups (and the upcoming one as nicely) whereas a small nation like Belgium, which has made speedy strides within the sport in a brief interval – culminating within the World Cup-Olympic double – is denied dwelling benefit. And after they win on alien turf, their achievements should not duly recognised within the awards performed by the world governing physique of the game.
It’s well-known that the sheer numbers of Indians – not simply within the nation however around the globe – and their prolific exercise on social media and different voting platforms can skew any contest of their favour. One simply has to enchantment to their patriotic and nationalistic (or ought to we are saying jingoistic) instincts to get their fingers into motion.
Congratulations to all winners of the Males’s Awards!#HockeyStarsAwards
Participant of the 12 months – @13harmanpreet
Goalkeeper of the 12 months – @16Sreejesh
Rising Star of the 12 months – @VivekSagarpras1
Coach of the 12 months – @reidgj
— Worldwide Hockey Federation (@FIH_Hockey) October 6, 2021
In any other case, what number of severe hockey followers around the globe would name Harmanpreet Singh the perfect participant on the planet, forward of Belgian duo Alexander Hendrickx and Arthur van Doren?
Or place Gurjit Kaur forward of Dutchwomen Eva de Goede and Frederique Matla? It’s possible that a lot of the ‘followers’ who voted for the candidates representing India didn’t care or hadn’t heard about who else was within the operating. It’s true that the voting system (50 per cent nationwide captains and coaches, 25 per cent media and the remainder followers) was determined a lot beforehand, however no one may have predicted that it may present such logic-defying outcomes.
Congratulations to all winners of the Ladies’s Awards! #HockeyStarsAwards
Participant of the 12 months – @gurjit02
Goalkeeper of the 12 months – @savitahockey
Rising Star of the 12 months – Sharmila Devi
Coach of the 12 months – @SjoerdMarijne
— Worldwide Hockey Federation (@FIH_Hockey) October 6, 2021
Similar to no one predicted that the 2019 50-over World Cup ultimate could possibly be determined by which workforce hit extra boundaries.
The hockey awards develop into much more eye-popping because the interval coated was from January 2020 to the Tokyo Olympics.
Indian dominance of the net house is now an acknowledged reality. One simply wants to have a look at the trolling any less-than-laudatory remark suffers on the fingers of the self-proclaimed defenders of nationwide honour.
Sachin Tendulkar getting the Laureus Sporting Second of the final twenty years was one other occasion of emotion and sheer numbers trumping logic. He would have been favorite to return out on high anyway, even earlier than Virat Kohli urged his legion of followers to vote for his paaji.
Equally, Amitabh Bachchan was as soon as voted the best actor, on the idea of Indians’ voting prowess. It exhibits which nation has the most individuals idle to revive nationwide honour on-line. There’s just one nation with an even bigger inhabitants than India – China, however they rarely win such awards regardless of being a bona fide sporting superpower. Perhaps, they don’t have a lot expertise in voting!
Profitable isn’t all the things
Coming again to the FIH awards, one can argue that the Europeans, Australians, New Zealanders and Argentines may have voted in greater numbers for his or her candidates. Solely 19 of the 42 European member associations had been represented within the voting course of, whereas virtually 3,00,000 followers participated – a report. Protected to say, a big proportion of them would have gone for the profitable candidates.
Those that carried out the perfect on the sector – the place it truly mattered – appeared to consider, rightly or wrongly, that profitable the largest prize within the sport would maintain all the things else.
They wouldn’t have bargained for some one-eyed ‘followers’ ignoring all elements besides the nationality of the candidate and the workforce a coach helmed.
It might be worthwhile to go for a jury of former gamers and directors who perceive the sport and what goes behind excellence of the very best order. In any other case, such awards would find yourself rewarding recognition greater than high quality.
One shudders to suppose what would occur if soccer follows hockey’s mannequin of recognising its finest. Perhaps, the stranglehold of Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo over the coveted Ballon d’Or would have ended a lot earlier than it truly did – courtesy a sure Sunil Chhetri and the suddenly-emerging legion of Indian followers!
It additionally helps that nobody nation drives the income for soccer in the way in which India does for cricket and hockey.